If you've decided to go gas which it seems you have I won't go into the whole gas vs charcoal thing. I'm a gas man myself. The main thing to realize is that you will NEVER go wrong with Weber. I'm going to leave the money issue out as well because only you (and your wife
) knows you budget. They are both great grills. What it mainly boils down to me is size. Do you want or need that much cooking space? The features beyond that are comparable and others can be added as accessories. That said, I too am an elated D owner.
Enjoy your new grill whichever you choose.